diff --git a/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_antag.dm b/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_antag.dm
index 9823168d5130..a2d53644b1fb 100644
--- a/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_antag.dm
+++ b/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_antag.dm
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@
 		return FALSE
 	var/datum/weakref/target_ref = WEAKREF(target_mind)
 	LAZYOR(all_sac_targets, target_ref)
-	LAZYSET(current_sac_targets, target_ref, getFlatIcon(target_body, defdir = SOUTH))
+	LAZYSET(current_sac_targets, target_ref, TRUE)
 	return TRUE
 
 /**
diff --git a/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_living_heart.dm b/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_living_heart.dm
index 63a04df10399..77a0ea9494cc 100644
--- a/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_living_heart.dm
+++ b/monkestation/code/modules/antagonists/heretic/heretic_living_heart.dm
@@ -17,7 +17,13 @@
 			continue
 		var/sac_name = trimtext(target_mind.name || living_target.real_name || living_target.name)
 		living_targets[sac_name] = living_target
-		targets_to_choose[sac_name] = heretic_datum.current_sac_targets[target_ref]
+		var/mutable_appearance/target_appearance = new
+		target_appearance.appearance = living_target.appearance
+		target_appearance.setDir(SOUTH)
+		target_appearance.pixel_x = 0
+		target_appearance.pixel_y = 0
+		target_appearance.pixel_z = 0
+		targets_to_choose[sac_name] = target_appearance
 
 	// If we don't have a last tracked name, open a radial to set one.
 	// If we DO have a last tracked name, we skip the radial if they right click the action.