Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Closed lightning channel, where does the sats go? #1298

Open
andysavage opened this issue Sep 7, 2024 · 8 comments
Open

Closed lightning channel, where does the sats go? #1298

andysavage opened this issue Sep 7, 2024 · 8 comments

Comments

@andysavage
Copy link

andysavage commented Sep 7, 2024

Hi I closed the lightning channel and waited to see the sats back in my on-chain wallet, but now there is no sign of them anywhere. How can I see where they should go? Would they go to the original wallet I sent in funds from or does mutiny have its own onchain wallet, cos I cannot see one. Balance is entirely zero
Thanks

mutiny1
mutiny2

@marksftw
Copy link

You can try loading it into Sparrow with your 12 word seed phrase. Be sure to use the derivation path at this link: https://github.com/MutinyWallet/mutiny-web/wiki/Recovery?ref=blog.mutinywallet.com#on-chain

@andysavage
Copy link
Author

You can try loading it into Sparrow with your 12 word seed phrase. Be sure to use the derivation path at this link: https://github.com/MutinyWallet/mutiny-web/wiki/Recovery?ref=blog.mutinywallet.com#on-chain

Hi thanks for replying. I tried this but it gives an empty wallet. Also I dont understand the stuff about derivation path, I tried pasting in m/86'/0'/0' as in the link you gave but this it says is invald so I am misunderstanding something. I was unable to find anything relevant that I could copy from the mutuny site either, apart from the 12 word passphrase.

This is very different to what I'm used to!

@stasgnikcats
Copy link

I have this same issue from 9-25-2024. I closed a channel (I think it was with Zeus). Funds not showing. As the user above noted, Sparrow does not allow you to generate a wallet with custom derivation path m/86'/0'/0'. Here are my logs which don't go back to the 25th unfortunately so I figure they will not be worth anything. The channel close note reads as if the LSP performed a justice transaction due to non consensus of fee:
IMG_3067

@DanConwayDev
Copy link

@andysavage that's the taproot derivation path. I also found that I couldn't manually enter the derivation path with sparrow but it loads that derivation you select taproot under script type.
Unfortunately like @stasgnikcats, I cannot find the output of the force close transaction under that derivation. I set the gap limit to 200 to no avail.

@DanConwayDev
Copy link

I've heard that the standard derivation path is not used for forced channels. Its calcuated based on your channel state. apparently LDK has some recovery tools if you still have your channel state (you can export this under Emergency Kit) and maybe your seed words. I'll investigate later and report back.

@andysavage
Copy link
Author

Thanks, I have the seed phrase and I downloaded the state. I lost browser history etc and the logs only go back about 2 weeks when I re-entered my seed into the website to see if I could empty it.

@stasgnikcats
Copy link

@DanConwayDev thanks for looking into this. I was able to locate the 86 TR derivation path transactions and pinpoint the force close transaction. To me, it seems like Mutiny did not have a matching fee rate to Zeus. It appears to be around half (2 sats/vB) of what Zeus was using for their consensus (4 sats/vB). In this case, Zeus initiated a justice transaction and just stole my funds. The bitcoin has subsequently been combined with other UTXOs and transferred multiple times since I demanded a close on 9/25. This is the address of the force close tx: https://mempool.space/address/bc1pujytq58vctrajxg2r2uczgy6ttgkdgfy8xy5grmpfftr5vu8xlzq7mrp6y

Short of trying to work with Zeus directly, I'm not sure if there is anything else I can do to get my funds back. I have a feeling this will cause further issues for others who are being instructed to close channels as Mutiny sunsets....

@stasgnikcats
Copy link

Update: I was able to troubleshoot with Zeus and I am squared away. Thanks for taking a look!

OP still may not have been rectified...

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants