build error related to preinstall script: "npx only-allow pnpm"

[cvarjao]

• I'm submitting a ...
  [x] bug report
  [ ] feature request
  [ ] question about the decisions made in the repository
  [ ] question about how to use this project

• Summary
  We use PEX with OWF Credo and Bifold. pnpm is not supported by react native, is it possible to not enforce consumers of this library to also use pnpm?
  we are getting a build error:

  ➤ YN0000: │ @sphereon/pex@npm:3.3.3 STDERR sh: 1: only-allow: not found
  ➤ YN0009: │ @sphereon/pex@npm:3.3.3 couldn't be built successfully (exit code 127, logs can be found here: /tmp/xfs-42e00f6b/build.log)

• Other information (e.g. detailed explanation, stack traces, related issues, suggestions how to fix, links for us to have context, eg. StackOverflow, personal fork, etc.)

[nklomp]

Why is it building PEX? We provide releases, so I am unsure why this is happening to begin with.
We are using RN for our own wallet as well and never have seen anything like this.

To add. The preinstall fase is the phase before installing the deps for PEX itself. External solutions using PEX as a dep should not be bothered by that at all. Almost all of our libs and SDKs use PNPM, but we also have projects using yarn and even npm. None have seen this happen and I cannot see how our choice of package/build system would interfere with external projects, unless PEX would be build as part of the solution, or a link to Github is used as dep

[cvarjao]

@nklomp , do you use yarn? it might a yarn quirk:
https://yarnpkg.com/advanced/lifecycle-scripts#postinstall

For backwards compatibility, the preinstall and install scripts, if presents, are called right before running the postinstall script from the same package. In general, prefer using postinstall over those two.

[nklomp]

Yes. I know of multiple RN wallets AFAIK all using yarn and our PEX lib. Is the link to the repo public? If so could you provide me with a link so I can have a look?

[nklomp]

You mentioned Credo. They are also using our pnpm based libs with a yarn package manager
https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/credo-ts/tree/main

@TimoGlastra Do you know if you had to do anything special to make that work (shouldn't be the case, but just doublechecking)

[TimoGlastra]

Hmm it seems Bifold is using Yarn 3, which works very different from Yarn V1 (which we're using for Credo).

However, we're using Yarn V3 in the Paradym Wallet (https://github.com/animo/paradym-wallet) and that's also been working fine until now

[TimoGlastra]

But it seems the preinstall has only been introduced since PEX v3.3.1. So maybe that's what's causing the issue?

[cre8]

@cvarjao can you provide some steps to reproduce the error?
I cloned the bitfold repo and tried to install it with yarn v3.3.1, but it failed on Windows (some errors with node-gyp-build). However yarn build worked fine.

[cre8]

@nklomp @TimoGlastra it seems that preinstall causes also problems in other projects, see ethereum-optimism/optimism#9805 pnpm/only-allow#11

[cvarjao]

Their behaviour is similar to ours. It seems to always work from our laptops, but often (not always) fails from github action.

[cre8]

@cvarjao can you provide some links to the failed github actions? Maybe it's a bad configuration that triggers this behaviour.

[cre8]

@nklomp it seems that pnpm can make some problems with latest versions for pnpm, yarn and npm (the package last update is form last year).

Another apporach is to use the engine field like:

  "engines": {
    "node": ">=18",
    "npm": "please use pnpm"
  },

However this does not prevent the npm install script from being executed and create the package-lock file (but it will fail in the end "successfully")

npm WARN EBADENGINE Unsupported engine {
npm WARN EBADENGINE   package: '@sphereon/[email protected]',
npm WARN EBADENGINE   required: { node: '>=18', npm: 'use pnpm' },
npm WARN EBADENGINE   current: { node: 'v20.11.1', npm: '10.2.4' }
npm WARN EBADENGINE }

It is btw the same behaviour like "preinstall": "npx only-allow pnpm", so there is technically no job that is executed before install

@cvarjao could you make the patch file for bifold and check if the engine approach will work better for you?

[cvarjao]

@cre8 , we can try. Right now we have patched to remove the "preinstall" script:
https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/bifold-wallet/blob/main/.yarn/patches/%40sphereon-pex-npm-3.3.3-144d9252ec.patch

I don't know if you can see all the GHA build logs, but here is an example:
https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/bifold-wallet/actions/runs/8886740708/job/24400750310