You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Moving from module version 0.58.2 to 0.60.0, Terraform is creating unnecessarily noisy diffs for empty list values. It doesn't impact whether a change is detected on the task definition or not, just the size of the diff, presumably due to the way Terraform is treating [] and omitted the same.
Pasting part of the diff below
~ {
- mountPoints = []
name ="log-router"- portMappings = []
- volumesFrom = []
# (8 unchanged attributes hidden)
},
~ {
~ environment = [
# (2 unchanged elements hidden)
{
name ="DD_LOGS_ENABLED"
value ="true"
},
~ {
name ="DD_VERSION"
~ value ="fake-tag-for-template"->"326d5e5572a9f7b4fd8c54fa243a84af094dac5b"
},
{
name ="ECS_FARGATE"
value ="true"
},
]
- mountPoints = []
name ="datadog"- volumesFrom = []
# (7 unchanged attributes hidden)
},
Expected Behavior
Here's a diff using 0.58.2. Notice that mountPoints, portMappings, and volumesFrom don't show that they are being removed.
{
cpu =0
environment = []
essential =true
firelensConfiguration = {
options = {
enable-ecs-log-metadata ="true"
}
type ="fluentbit"
}
image ="public.ecr.aws/aws-observability/aws-for-fluent-bit:latest"
logConfiguration = {
logDriver ="awslogs"
options = {
awslogs-group ="main/fromagerie-job-migrate-from-unified-keysets"
awslogs-region ="us-west-2"
awslogs-stream-prefix ="fluentbit"
}
}
mountPoints = []
name ="log-router"
portMappings = []
readonlyRootFilesystem =false
user ="0"
volumesFrom = []
},
~ {
~ environment = [
# (2 unchanged elements hidden)
{
name ="DD_LOGS_ENABLED"
value ="true"
},
~ {
name ="DD_VERSION"
~ value ="fake-tag-for-template"->"326d5e5572a9f7b4fd8c54fa243a84af094dac5b"
},
{
name ="ECS_FARGATE"
value ="true"
},
]
name ="datadog"# (9 unchanged attributes hidden)
},
] # forces replacement
Steps to Reproduce
Run plan on any task definition with changes that would cause the task definition to be replaced, where mountPoints or portMappings, etc, is omitted from the container definition or an [] is provided.
I think the problem is that the ECS task definition API is returning [] for list fields that are unset. Maybe these fields should be set to [] when not provided in the container definition as well? @go
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
mightyguava
changed the title
Terraform producing unnecessarily large diffs due to omitted lists
Terraform producing unnecessarily noisy diffs due to omitted lists
Jun 9, 2023
Describe the Bug
Moving from module version 0.58.2 to 0.60.0, Terraform is creating unnecessarily noisy diffs for empty list values. It doesn't impact whether a change is detected on the task definition or not, just the size of the diff, presumably due to the way Terraform is treating
[]
and omitted the same.Pasting part of the diff below
Expected Behavior
Here's a diff using 0.58.2. Notice that
mountPoints
,portMappings
, andvolumesFrom
don't show that they are being removed.Steps to Reproduce
Run plan on any task definition with changes that would cause the task definition to be replaced, where
mountPoints
orportMappings
, etc, is omitted from the container definition or an[]
is provided.Screenshots
No response
Environment
Terraform v1.4.6
on darwin_arm64
Additional Context
I think the problem is that the ECS task definition API is returning
[]
for list fields that are unset. Maybe these fields should be set to[]
when not provided in the container definition as well? @goThe text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: