diff --git a/Classes/Domain/Index/Queue/QueueItemRepository.php b/Classes/Domain/Index/Queue/QueueItemRepository.php
index bdf7dea692..44e92e0310 100644
--- a/Classes/Domain/Index/Queue/QueueItemRepository.php
+++ b/Classes/Domain/Index/Queue/QueueItemRepository.php
@@ -397,16 +397,20 @@ public function containsItem(string $itemType, int $itemUid): bool
      * @param string $itemType The item's type, usually a table name.
      * @param int $itemUid The item's uid
      * @param int $rootPageId
+     * @param string $indexingConfiguration
      * @return bool TRUE if the item is found in the queue, FALSE otherwise
      *
      * @throws DBALDriverException
      * @throws DBALException|\Doctrine\DBAL\DBALException
      */
-    public function containsItemWithRootPageId(string $itemType, int $itemUid, int $rootPageId): bool
+    public function containsItemWithRootPageId(string $itemType, int $itemUid, int $rootPageId, string $indexingConfiguration): bool
     {
         $queryBuilder = $this->getQueryBuilderForContainsMethods($itemType, $itemUid);
         return (bool)$queryBuilder
-            ->andWhere($queryBuilder->expr()->eq('root', $rootPageId))
+            ->andWhere(
+                $queryBuilder->expr()->eq('root', $rootPageId),
+                $queryBuilder->expr()->eq('indexing_configuration', $queryBuilder->createNamedParameter($indexingConfiguration))
+            )
             ->execute()
             ->fetchOne();
     }
diff --git a/Classes/IndexQueue/Queue.php b/Classes/IndexQueue/Queue.php
index 7bafdb4823..a030d023a2 100644
--- a/Classes/IndexQueue/Queue.php
+++ b/Classes/IndexQueue/Queue.php
@@ -220,7 +220,7 @@ protected function updateOrAddItemForAllRelatedRootPages(string $itemType, $item
                 continue;
             }
             $indexingPriority = $solrConfiguration->getIndexQueueIndexingPriorityByConfigurationName($indexingConfiguration);
-            $itemInQueueForRootPage = $this->containsItemWithRootPageId($itemType, $itemUid, $rootPageId);
+            $itemInQueueForRootPage = $this->containsItemWithRootPageId($itemType, $itemUid, $rootPageId, $indexingConfiguration);
             if ($itemInQueueForRootPage) {
                 // update changed time if that item is in the queue already
                 $changedTime = ($forcedChangeTime > 0) ? $forcedChangeTime : $this->getItemChangedTime($itemType, $itemUid);
@@ -482,13 +482,14 @@ public function containsItem(string $itemType, $itemUid): bool
      * @param int|string $itemUid The item's uid, usually an integer uid, could be a
      *      different value for non-database-record types.
      * @param int $rootPageId
+     * @param string $indexingConfiguration
      * @return bool TRUE if the item is found in the queue, FALSE otherwise
      * @throws DBALDriverException
      * @throws DBALException|\Doctrine\DBAL\DBALException
      */
-    public function containsItemWithRootPageId(string $itemType, $itemUid, int $rootPageId): bool
+    public function containsItemWithRootPageId(string $itemType, $itemUid, int $rootPageId, string $indexingConfiguration): bool
     {
-        return $this->queueItemRepository->containsItemWithRootPageId($itemType, (int)$itemUid, $rootPageId);
+        return $this->queueItemRepository->containsItemWithRootPageId($itemType, (int)$itemUid, $rootPageId, $indexingConfiguration);
     }
 
     /**