Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Outgoing connections not working after 2024.6 update #7058

Open
2 tasks done
zedd3v opened this issue Oct 23, 2024 · 45 comments
Open
2 tasks done

Outgoing connections not working after 2024.6 update #7058

zedd3v opened this issue Oct 23, 2024 · 45 comments
Labels
bug macOS Issues related to macOS

Comments

@zedd3v
Copy link

zedd3v commented Oct 23, 2024

Is it a bug?

  • I know this is an issue with the app, and contacting Mullvad support is not relevant.

I have checked if others have reported this already

  • I have checked the issue tracker to see if others have reported similar issues.

Current Behavior

Outgoing connections not working after 2024.6 update

The app also shows no outgoing ip
CleanShot 2024-10-24 at 01 17 09

These are the only out of place logs I found, idk if related
[DEBUG] no one is waiting for ICMP packet (V4(Icmpv4Packet { ...
[DEBUG] error decoding ICMP packet: MalformedPacket(NotIcmpv4Packet)

Expected Behavior

Expect it to work and show outgoing ip

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Install 2024.6
  2. Connect

Failure Logs

No response

Operating system version

macOS 15.0.1 (24A348)

Mullvad VPN app version

2024.6

Additional Information

Everything still functional on 2024.5 so its definitely 2024.6

@zedd3v zedd3v added the bug label Oct 23, 2024
@islamsaka
Copy link

I can confirm the issue for Macos 15.0.1 (24A348). After trying for OpenVPN/wireguard and sub-internal options, I couldn't fix the issue temporarily and was downgraded to 2024.5, and it seems to work fine.

@BionicBison05
Copy link

I have these symptoms when I point Mullvad at 127.0.0.1 for custom DNS with dnscrypt-proxy. I don't have any issues with a public custom DNS server or no custom DNS server though, so maybe that's a different issue. 2024.5 worked perfectly for me as well.

@beesyrupfactory
Copy link

beesyrupfactory commented Oct 24, 2024

I'm having the same problem. I might need to revert back to 2024.5. Tailscale and Mullvad were working fine together before on my mac, but now I keep getting dns-forward-failing and no-derp-connection errors.

@blue-devil
Copy link

I am here for this!
I have updated my macOS mullvad to 2024.6 and now I cannot browse any websites. Interestingly I can ping.
I have a linux machine with Mullvad 2024.5 and I have no problem with connection.

More: I have downloaded 2024.05 from github; uninstalled 2024.6 and installed 2024.5 on my macos and now I have internet back

@yww-sde
Copy link

yww-sde commented Oct 24, 2024

Same here, uninstall & reinstall by Homebrew, full access granted, macOS 14.7, can connect to any server, has IN IP, never get OUT IP for some reason, lead to all internet blocked.

@Mike-571
Copy link

I confirm with Sequoia 15.0.1 and Mullvad app 2024.6 : connectivity completely lost. I switched back to 2024.5.
Please, pull back macOS app 2024.6 and add a direct link to download 2024.5 for those who have applied the update.

@humblecoder
Copy link

I confirm with Sequoia 15.0.1 and Mullvad app 2024.6 : connectivity completely lost. I switched back to 2024.5. Please, pull back macOS app 2024.6 and add a direct link to download 2024.5 for those who have applied the update.

Same. MacOS 15.0.1. Uninstalled 2024.6 and reinstalled 2024.5. 🫠

@hulthe hulthe added the macOS Issues related to macOS label Oct 24, 2024
@dairymilkbatman
Copy link

Reverted back to wireguard-tools/mullvad to regain connectivity that was lost due to the app update 2024.6.

@MarkusPettersson98
Copy link
Contributor

Hello everyone, thanks for reporting. We have been made aware of the issue with the 2024.6 release on macOS and we are investigating it.

@ldexterldesign
Copy link

ldexterldesign commented Oct 24, 2024

Here we go again...

Sorry if I've missed it here, if a Mullvad (MV) version exists where this issue doesn't then please let me/us know so I/we can rollback?:
If yes then MV please enhance your testing before releases - issue is very 😞

Will be contacting support for a refund - unable to use my VPN properly for ages

Regards

@raksooo
Copy link
Member

raksooo commented Oct 24, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

@humblecoder
Copy link

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

Seems to work for me -- in the 30 second test I gave it. Loaded multiple browsers and ran a couple 3rd party "speed tests"

@MarkusPettersson98
Copy link
Contributor

MarkusPettersson98 commented Oct 24, 2024

Seems to work for me -- in the 30 second test I gave it. Loaded multiple browsers and ran a couple 3rd party "speed tests"

Thanks for the hasty feedback, it is very much appreciated! 💛

@tweaksalot
Copy link

Can you share what the fix is that’s in the test build?

@Mike-571
Copy link

It works here with Sequoia 15.0.1, Split tunneling (Safari can't be excluded, but it was already the case before) and LittleSnitch 6.1.2. I tried multiple browsers and after reboot. Good job

@zedd3v
Copy link
Author

zedd3v commented Oct 24, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

Works

@BionicBison05
Copy link

BionicBison05 commented Oct 24, 2024

I have these symptoms when I point Mullvad at 127.0.0.1 for custom DNS with dnscrypt-proxy. I don't have any issues with a public custom DNS server or no custom DNS server though, so maybe that's a different issue. 2024.5 worked perfectly for me as well.

No more issues with my custom DNS setup after updating to the dev build.

@Yell0whead
Copy link

Yell0whead commented Oct 24, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

This works. To note, Windows 11 running via Parallels encounters issues. States no Internet connection in Taskbar tray, and internet doesn't connect reliably in browser.

@piru
Copy link

piru commented Oct 24, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

This version fixes the issue for me, too.

@UndercoverGoose
Copy link

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

Just checked this build out for myself, and I am still running into DNS problems only when trying to run custom DNS outside of Mullvad. I am testing on Sequoia 15.1 (24B82). Specifically, trying to run Cloudflare WARP through their desktop application alongside Mullvad breaks all DNS resolution. However, defining a custom DNS within Mullvad does work properly. AFAIK everything else works, including split tunneling and Win11 Parallels (someone mentioned it not working above).

@nicolasharnois
Copy link

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

Seems to fix the issue on macOS 15.0.1 for me as well. I have another computer running macOS 15.0 (not yet upgraded to 15.0.1) with Mullvad 2024.6 and there are no issues on that one.

@nicolasharnois
Copy link

nicolasharnois commented Oct 24, 2024

This works. To note, Windows 11 running via Parallels encounters issues. States no Internet connection in Taskbar tray, and internet doesn't connect reliably in browser.

I'm seeing this as well. I switched to Bridged Network for the time being and it works, but this means no VPN for the VM.

@Artimunor
Copy link

raksooo

this works however it shows a security warning: "Your privacy might be at risk with this unsupported app version. Please update now."

@nijaru
Copy link

nijaru commented Oct 25, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

Working here.

I had the current issues with the 2024.6 beta and now with the release as well, but this build is working without noticeable issues.

@voltzd
Copy link

voltzd commented Oct 25, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

I was just sent this version via email by support, has fixed the issue for me too but I needed to update my macOS or restart for it to work, not sure which one as I just updated.

@nicolasembleton
Copy link

I've just tried on MacOS Sonoma 14.7 (23H124) with the latest 2024.7-beta1 and the issue seems to be the same than 2024.6. Ingoing is ok but outgoing never gets filled. I get lots of really weird behaviors on the UI such as impossible to switch to another location, switches seem to not be visually responding, like the UI thread was overloaded with something and never gotten CPU time back. Pretty strange. Had to downgrade to 2024.5 for it to work. Behavior when connecting is quite different on 2024.5 than 2024.6+, whereby "creating quantum connection" takes a good 10 seconds before the "out" field gets filled, whereas on 2024.6+, it is very quick, but it never gets filled. Not sure whether this extra info helps or not.

@raksooo
Copy link
Member

raksooo commented Oct 25, 2024

We've now released 2024.7-beta1 which contains the same fix as in the dev-build posted above. Please try out the beta! Thanks to everyone who helped test the dev-build! If you run into any issues on future betas, please report the issue either with the "Report a problem" function in the app or here.

@nicolasembleton Could you send a problem report in the app and write that it is in response to this issue, and we'll take a look!

@nicolasharnois
Copy link

We've now released 2024.7-beta1 which contains the same fix as in the dev-build posted above. Please try out the beta!

Looks good at my end, thanks @raksooo. There's still the issue of Shared Network no longer working in Parallels (Win 11 VM, Edge returns DNS_PROBE_FINISHED_NO_INTERNET).

@beesyrupfactory
Copy link

When using 2024.5 release, I was able to run Tailscale as an exit node on my computer using Mullvad VPN.

I just tried to run Tailscale with 2024.7-beta1, and I'm still seeing dns-forward-failing on the Tailscale side. As this is the case, I will need to revert back to 2024.5 again.

@ldexterldesign
Copy link

macos 15.1 (24B82)
mullvad 2024.7-beta1

AirDrop (still) broken

Regards

@Artimunor
Copy link

Artimunor commented Oct 27, 2024

macos 15.1 (24B82) mullvad 2024.7-beta1

AirDrop (still) broken

Regards

i can confirm that in the 2024.6-devbuild Airdrop works
will there be a fixed version of 2024.6 released for mac? or do we have to wait for 2024.7 ?

@vanyauhalin
Copy link

Perhaps my issue is related to this one. After the update, when starting Docker services, any connection to the Internet stops functioning. This was reproduced when working with Docker versions 4.29.0 and 4.35.0 as well. I reverted to Mullvad version 2024.5, and this solved my problem.

@AlecGower
Copy link

AlecGower commented Oct 28, 2024

Hi! We have a potential fix that we would appreciate if you all could help us try out! It's somewhat difficult to reproduce so we can't reliably test it on our computers. Here's a test build that includes the fix: https://releases.mullvad.net/desktop/builds/2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247/MullvadVPN-2024.6-dev-8e55ad%2Btest-20247.pkg

Let us know how well it works for you!

This fix worked for me as well (M1 Pro Sonoma 14.7). For the time being, until this is incorporated in a new release, should I revert back to 2024.5? I got a warning message in the app saying this test version is unsupported.

@MarkusPettersson98
Copy link
Contributor

This fix worked for me as well (M1 Pro Sonoma 14.7). For the time being, until this is incorporated in a new release, should I revert back to 2024.5? I got a warning message in the app saying this test version is unsupported.

The fix has been released in the current beta: https://github.com/mullvad/mullvadvpn-app/releases/tag/2024.7-beta1
We are looking at releasing a stable version asap, but in the meantime you could install this beta release. It will not complain about being "unsupported" 😊

@ldexterldesign
Copy link

ldexterldesign commented Oct 30, 2024

macos 15.1 (24B82) mullvad 2024.7-beta1

AirDrop (still) broken

Regards

Please ignore this

I neglected to turn on local network sharing after a fresh install of your beta 🙈

Apologies

@MarkusPettersson98
Copy link
Contributor

2024.7 has been released as stable: https://github.com/mullvad/mullvadvpn-app/releases/tag/2024.7 🚀

@vanyauhalin
Copy link

Perhaps my issue is related to this one. After the update, when starting Docker services, any connection to the Internet stops functioning. This was reproduced when working with Docker versions 4.29.0 and 4.35.0 as well. I reverted to Mullvad version 2024.5, and this solved my problem.

I have just updated to 2024.7. At first glance, my problem appears to be solved. Thank you, @MarkusPettersson98, for such a quick fix. ❤️

@nicolasembleton
Copy link

We've now released 2024.7-beta1 which contains the same fix as in the dev-build posted above. Please try out the beta! Thanks to everyone who helped test the dev-build! If you run into any issues on future betas, please report the issue either with the "Report a problem" function in the app or here.

@nicolasembleton Could you send a problem report in the app and write that it is in response to this issue, and we'll take a look!

Sorry for the late reply. I just did and mentioned the symptoms (but forgot to mention this particular issue#). I tried the latest stable version and I'm still having the same issue on Sonoma.

@Mike-571
Copy link

Problem solved. Thanks for your great support.

@islamsaka
Copy link

I can confirm the issue for Macos 15.0.1 (24A348). After trying for OpenVPN/wireguard and sub-internal options, I couldn't fix the issue temporarily and was downgraded to 2024.5, and it seems to work fine.

I've tested the 2024.7 release on the same device, and everything is fine. Thanks for the quick fix.

@beesyrupfactory
Copy link

My apologies, but I've just tested the final release of 2024.7, and I'm still having issues while running a Tailscale exit node on my Mac while running Mullvad VPN. If this requires a new request, please let me know and I will be happy to share steps to reproduce this behavior. This does not happen on the 2024.5 release of Mullvad VPN. The error on the Tailscale client side is dns-forward-failing. I know this has nothing to do with Mullvad, but the fact that Tailscale exit node is still working when I revert to 2024.5 means that there is some change that I need to account for on the Mullvad side.

@floq-design
Copy link

2024.7 still not working for me with local development setup. Using Valet and TLD .test.
Reverting back to 2024.5 works fine.

@jmonday
Copy link

jmonday commented Nov 1, 2024

2024.7 is not working for me either. I'm using dnsmasq with local web development. When connected to the VPN, my local development environment doesn't respond as expected. I see the "this site can't be reached" with a DNS_PROBE_POSSIBLE error.

After downgrading to 2024.5, my local development site responds as expected.

@mdl054
Copy link

mdl054 commented Nov 4, 2024

Can confirm no outgoing connections working while using shared networking in Parallels, irrespective of platform used (linux, mac, windows, etc) on 2024.7. As with other people, downgrading to 2024.5 seems to repair this functionality.

@Mike-571
Copy link

Mike-571 commented Nov 4, 2024

Using manual DNS within host, as indicated on this page : https://mullvad.net/en/help/dns-over-https-and-dns-over-tls#win11 But it's a lot slower than automatic DNS.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
bug macOS Issues related to macOS
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests