Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Fermatas over rests get exported twice #89

Closed
karend27 opened this issue May 6, 2018 · 3 comments
Closed

Fermatas over rests get exported twice #89

karend27 opened this issue May 6, 2018 · 3 comments
Assignees

Comments

@karend27
Copy link

karend27 commented May 6, 2018

When fermatas are placed over rests in Sibelius, they are encoded twice in the MEI output, both as an attribute within the rest element, and separately as a fermata element. This doesn't happen when fermatas are placed above notes, which are only encoded once as a separate fermata element.

To be consistent with how notes are treated, can fermatas above rests only be encoded as a fermata element, please.

<measure xml:id="m-1176" n="40">
							<staff xml:id="m-1177" n="1">
								<layer xml:id="m-1178" n="1">
									<note xml:id="m-1179" dur="breve" dur.ges="2048p" layer="1" oct="4" oct.ges="3" pname="d" pnum="50" staff="1" stem.dir="down">
										<verse xml:id="m-1187" n="1">
											<syl xml:id="m-1188" wordpos="t">e</syl>
										</verse>
									</note>
									<note xml:id="m-1180" dur="1" dur.ges="1024p" layer="1" oct="4" oct.ges="3" pname="e" pnum="52" staff="1" stem.dir="down">
										<verse xml:id="m-1189" n="1">
											<syl xml:id="m-1190" wordpos="i">la</syl>
										</verse>
									</note>
									<note xml:id="m-1181" artic="stacc" dur="1" dur.ges="1024p" layer="1" oct="4" oct.ges="3" pname="g" pnum="55" staff="1" stem.dir="down">
										<verse xml:id="m-1191" n="1">
											<syl xml:id="m-1192" wordpos="i">ue</syl>
										</verse>
									</note>
									<note xml:id="m-1182" dur="1" dur.ges="1024p" layer="1" oct="4" oct.ges="3" pname="a" pnum="57" staff="1" stem.dir="down">
										<verse xml:id="m-1193" n="1">
											<syl xml:id="m-1194" wordpos="m">ri</syl>
										</verse>
									</note>
									<note xml:id="m-1184" artic="stacc" dur="1" dur.ges="1024p" layer="1" oct="4" oct.ges="3" pname="a" pnum="57" staff="1" stem.dir="down">
										<verse xml:id="m-1195" n="1">
											<syl xml:id="m-1196" wordpos="t">te</syl>
										</verse>
									</note>
								</layer>
							</staff>
							<staff xml:id="m-1197" n="2">
								<layer xml:id="m-1198" n="1">
									<note xml:id="m-1199" dur="breve" dur.ges="2048p" layer="1" oct="3" oct.ges="2" pname="g" pnum="43" staff="2" stem.dir="up">
										<verse xml:id="m-1204" n="1">
											<syl xml:id="m-1205" wordpos="t">mour</syl>
										</verse>
									</note>
									<rest xml:id="m-1200" dur="long" dur.ges="4096p" fermata="above" />
								</layer>
							</staff>
							<staff xml:id="m-1206" n="3">
								<layer xml:id="m-1207" n="1">
									<note xml:id="m-1208" dur="breve" dur.ges="2048p" layer="1" oct="3" oct.ges="2" pname="g" pnum="43" staff="3" stem.dir="up" />
									<rest xml:id="m-1209" dur="long" dur.ges="4096p" />
								</layer>
							</staff>
							<fermata xml:id="m-1183" form="norm" layer="1" shape="angular" staff="1" startid="#m-1182" />
							<fermata xml:id="m-1201" form="norm" layer="1" shape="curved" staff="2" startid="#m-1200" />
						</measure>
@karend27
Copy link
Author

karend27 commented May 6, 2018

screen shot 2018-05-06 at 10 41 20

@th-we
Copy link
Member

th-we commented May 6, 2018

Thanks for taking the time to report this (as well as #87 and #88), Karen. If nobody else takes on these issues and you're interested in them being fixed sooner rather than later, I'd be grateful for a message in about two weeks. Right now, I've no capacity left for looking at them.

@th-we
Copy link
Member

th-we commented Sep 14, 2021

This is fixed by now, but there are still some fermata issues (see #187).

@th-we th-we closed this as completed Sep 14, 2021
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

3 participants