[Feature] Submitter User Rating Display

[echo6ix]

In a community-driven/crowd sourced platform, the credibility of data submitted is paramount. Just as eBay uses seller and buyer ratings to build trust and gauge reliability, our platform would benefit from displaying a prominent "user rating" of submitters when other users are voting on their submissions.

Essentially, the user rating displays the submitters track record. It would be based on the ratio of accepted to failed submissions along with the duration of their member status, and total amount of submissions.

Displayed adjacent to their username, this would immediately give voters a clear sense of the submitter's track record. By knowing the reputation of a submitter, voters can assess the likelihood that a submission is reliable, or better yet lacking a seasoned reputation voters can increase their scrutiny or skepticism of submissions, hopefully leading to more accurate and confident voting outcomes.

Example 1

Attached is an example of how this could be displayed adjacent to every submission.

We display their short term rating and total stats within the last 4 weeks to gauge their short term reputation, and a link or a possible hover card that displays detailed status. See below.

Example 2. Detailed ratings

A more detailed look at user ratings broken down by time frames and by StashDB categories. This could be telling because some submissions, such as performer edits are much more straight forward, and could skew a rating when combined in totality with the other category submissions.

This is peripherally related to #417, but I'd argue a basic ebay style user rating is more straight forward and informative, where gamification badges are more for community engagement.

Edit

Adding more detail to the original post

Color coded rating?

Adding color coding to the numeric ratings -- along the lines of what I have displayed in the attached images -- would provide a quick visual reference of the user's reputation and compliment the numeric rating, making it easier to interpret the ratings at a glance.

• Green. Rating is within a good standing
• Amber. Rating is not good but not bad.
• Red. Rating is suboptimal.

I think the admin and seasoned voters can decide the actual numeric ranges of what constitutes these definitions.

More alternate examples

This concept is a bit more streamlined, taking more inspiration from eBay, and less verbose, where the schema is

{Username} ({total submissions})
{total rating}% rating ({recent rating}% in last 4 weeks})

On hover of total submission anchor, a card with rating details can appear

Note: I know the stats in the conceptual images do not add up 😅