Skip to content

July 8th notes on Options for symbol

John Foliot edited this page Jul 8, 2019 · 5 revisions

Currently favoring a hybrid of Option 4 with ideas from Option 6.

Option 4 - A hybrid of BIC reference numbers or common terms

<span data-symbol="12322">ability</span>

OR

<span data-symbol="ability">ability</span>

In discussion, using the BIC reference number as our #Key number (or Master numeric ID number) allows both common term references (precedent: CSS color values) as well as the ability to create a custom mapping table, which allows for the support of multiple symbol sets - all that is required is a mapping table against the common #Key number.

I believe we are also in agreement that providing a full URL to the specific symbol is too heavy an author burden, and demands a lot of repeated (and thus redundant) code. Helper applications should be created in such a fashion as to take the #Key number or common term and "run with it" without the author providing a fully resolving URI.

Open questions

  • How many 'common terms' should we support? 100? 250? 500? 1000? (Bliss currently supports 5825 symbols as of July 8, 2019)
  • Where will the mapping table of common terms to Master ID Numbers be hosted?
  • Who is responsible for the drafting and maintenance of that mapping table?
  • How do we reference the Master ID Numbers in a document? (see Option 6 Ideas below)

Option 6 - additional implementation - linking in metadata to a mapping file

  • We need to continue to explore HOW we can reference the Master ID Numbers or an external or custom mapping file.
  • Suggestions include using <link rel="personalization" scr="mymappingsfile.html> or Schema.org's accessibilityFeature property (although we will need to create/request a new Accessibility term to meet our purpose). One advantage of using Schema.org's mechanism is that it supports Microdata, RDFa and JSON notation formats.
  • John expressed wariness of using an XML format

Example mapping file showing both "common terms" as well as an illustration of mapping to the Wordnet taxonomy.

(I selected 5 random terms for illustrative purposes only)

Master Numeric ID
(Will reference the Bliss numbers taxonomy ONLY)
Bliss Definition
Common Term (precedent: CSS named color values - i.e. "red" = "#ff0000") Custom Mapping to specific symbols taxonomy
(such as wordnet or other corpus)
Rendered Symbol (defaults to the Bliss set unless there is a specific mapping file provided*)
12322 ability,capability,capacity,potential ability {05207437} Symbol for ability
12328 accessory accessory {02674410} Symbol for accessory
12340 adolescence adolescence {15172810} Symbol for adolescence
12345 advice, counsel, recommendation advice {06684229} Symbol for advice
12362 alligator, crocodile {none**} {01701075} Symbol for alligator
* How to map the external file is TBD - there are multiple options/proposals.
** While the taxonomical term of 'alligator, crocodile' is part of the terms in Bliss, I am excluding it as being 'outside' of a Common list of 500 terms, for illustrative purposes only.
Clone this wiki locally